Q.C Presiding Panelist Tony Willoughby Panelist Dated September 16 2002 DISSENTING OPINION The Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy UDRP is a mandatory administrative proceeding in which the Complainant must prove three elements i

States of America and Mr Tony Willoughby of London United Kingdom to be Co-panelists The Center transmitted to all Panelists a form of Statement of Acceptance and requested from each a Declaration of Impartiality and Independence All Panelists

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Sole Panelist Dated September 5 2002 D2002 0651 181 189 end users on line A Z in depth Australia wide pre date second guess post dates On well known australiayellowpages com australianyellowpages //www

Complaint is dismissed Tony Willoughby Sole Panelist Dated August 31 2002 D2002 0634 D 21039 hensotherm firestop.net firestop.com firestop.org fire proof on line pre date dates ill equipped hensotherm-firestop net com org and

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Presiding Panelist David Plant Panelist Dated July 22 2002 Dissenting Opinion I am dissenting because I do not agree with the findings of the majority decision My position is that in making such a

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Sole Panelist Dated July 9 2002 D2002 0460 CH 1211 14 18 non governmental profit 3 11 12 on line site Q Library multi lingual e mails 19 mail commercial isoquality com isoaudit isoconsultant net

The Complaint is dismissed Tony Willoughby Sole Panelist Dated June 5 2002 D2002 0345 biocare diagnostics.com diagnostics.co.uk //www.biocare inter partes one page Scientific com biocare-diagnostics biocarediagnostics //www biocare co uk 9807 43

Panel appointing Diane Cabell Tony Willoughby and M Scott Donahey each of whom had previously submitted a Statement of Acceptance and Declaration of Impartiality and Independence M Scott Donahey was designated Presiding Panelist 4 Factual

to the appointment of Tony Willoughby Esq as presiding panelist He is biased because he was also panelist in the administrative panel decision Emillio Pucci SRL v Mailbank.com Inc Case No D2000-1786 WIPO March 19 2001 In that decision it

The complaint is dismissed Tony Willoughby Sole Panelist Dated April 30 2002 D2002 0090 Kapelle op den Bos Belgian based re filed filing N V A G P O eternit com //www i e November December partner investor www.eternit.com

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Presiding Panelist Anna Carabelli Panelist Clive Lincoln Elliott Panelist Dated May 16 2002 D2002 0233 52 I 20154 33100 non exhaustive would be S p A s a wwwilsole24ore com www ilsole24ore 6 2 and or

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Single Panelist Dated May 13 2002 D2002 0287 Toronto Dominion wide ranging well known on line mis spelling out of pocket print ups non exhaustive commercial long term would be englisharbor com d b a

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Sole Panelist Dated April 27 2002 D2002 0138 bayer healthcare.org healthcare.net healthcare.biz polymers.net polymers.biz polymers.info chemicals.org chemicals.net chemicals.info chemicals.biz

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Sole Panelist Dated April 15 2002 D2002 0199 41 51 Colgate Palmolive pre requisite early to mid dating day newsouthernrailway com Joker co uk £1 5 i e t a and or case upper Plaintiff Complainant

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Sole Panelist Dated April 11 2002 C953978 LRMS D2002 0106 well known D2000 0003 10 84 non commercial exhaustive sub paragraph S A 1 The 2 adecco info 3 Procedural 4 Factual e g 111 srdom@hotmail com 5

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Presiding Panelist M Scott Donahey Esq Panelist Susanna H.S Leong Panelist Dated April 10 2002 2001 1392 98144 2734 99/16 20 US based Thailand Thai speaking non distinctive exhaustive Amazon com A R

John R Keys Jr Esq Panelist Tony Willoughby Esq Panelist Dated March 27 2002 D2001 1417 three member out of pocket 123 1234 common law AF 0563 0695 1195 1121 D2000 0624 non airport U S A hongkongairport com hkairport //www thriftys afternic 500

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Sole Panelist Dated March 20 2002 D2001 1484 jcb equipment.com plant.com sales.com spares.com equipment.uk.com parts.uk.com plant.uk.com sales.uk.com spares.uk.com Domain Name Dispute Resolution msd

to the Complainant Tony Willoughby Presiding Panelist Sandra Sellers Panelist Bahieldin Elibrachy Panelist Dated March 19 2002 D2001 1370 Coca Cola McCann Erickson 3 letter media related non exhaustive sub paragraph ex employer U A E S

Panelists Paul E Mason and Tony Willoughby and Presiding Panelist Mr Desmond Ryan having filed Statements of Acceptance and Declaration of Impartiality and Independence the Panel was appointed on January 14 2002 3.8 The language of the